departments ::


hip.hop :: reviews

Alicia Keys :: The Diary of Alicia Keys

J Records, December 2003

by Jessie Nelson

Alicia Keys has been in the soul music kitchen cooking up grooves for her second album The Diary of Alicia Keys. What she came up with was a blend of funk, soul and hip hop that shows where her roots are. The music has a little more edge than today’s blend, termed “neo-soul”; and that razor-blade edge gives it it’s dose of funk - simple but heavy drum grooves propel the tunes, violin licks ala “Saturday Night Fever” soundtrack disco, and piano underneath it all. Instrumentally, Keys shows her ability to really nail the soul genre- no contrived groove here - Marvin Gaye would be proud. Alicia’s “diary” consists of heartbreak and crush entries mostly, not too much introspective musing to be found in her musical notebook. The catchy hooks that come with all this emotional hoopla can be a lot of fun to sing along and relate to but 14 tracks is a little much to be repeating the same scenario. Call one a feminist but Miss Keys should be hip to the fact that a man is not essential for breathing. The track that stands out on this disc of groove and emotional instability is“Diary”, a slow jam with a simple story line (keeping secrets between two lovers) that allows the piano, drums and guitar to breathe and groove. Tony Toni Tone’ accompanies Keys as the male love interest and it’s a simple soulful vocal match with some “call and response” licks that make it all melt - just what good soul music should do. Alicia is etching her name on the wall in the soul music kitchen and joining the ranks of Erykah Badu and Jill Scott quite nicely. Welcome her in.

2004 1-42 Online

 

Drummer and music journalist extraordinaire, Jessie has worked for the Village Voice and co-edits Arizona State University's feminist magazine "GSPOT" (www.gspotasu.iwarp.com). Check out her funk/folk band Anti Organic at: www.antiorganic.com. Write her at drummgw4@hotmail.com